Avengers Endgame – The Captain America Problem | Comicstorian


The number one debate I’ve been having with Avengers Fans, what do you guys think?

Subscribe to Comicstorian:
Check out our Full Stories:

Gaming Channel!
VLOG Channel!
Start Your Collection Today!

DC Comics and Marvel Comics Fun at Comicstorian!
Twitter – @comicstorian
Instagram – @comicstorian

Do You Like Video Games?
The Gaming Channel!

All Music Provided by Epidemic Sound

Thank you for your Support!

#mcu #avengers #avengersendgame

Send hard copies or letters or fan mail or small animals to
Eligible Monster Productions or Comicstorian
PO Box 1869
Loveland 80539

About Comicstorian:
Comic Books dramatically read by the Eligible Monster Team. DC Comics, Marvel Comics and Indie alike, nothing is free from our dramatic readings.

Avengers Endgame – The Captain America Problem | Comicstorian


Find with tag :
comicstorian,comic books,dc,dc entertainment,marvel,storytelling,full story,dc universe,justice league,comic theories,avengers,superhero,injustice,miles morales,deadpool kills the marvel universe,batman,gwenpool,godspeed,doom patrol,marvel zombies,spider man


Comments (48)
June 7, 2019


June 7, 2019

The timeline in Avenger endgame basically works as Multiverse theory, just the fact that they went back in time at all created splittering timelines. When captain American went back in time he lived the remainder of his life in an Alternate timeline with Peggy. That's all we know, we don't know if he interfered with that timeline in anyway after the fact. But about multiverse theory, basically everything the avengers did in the past created a different universe, very similar to the orginal. While they did make an effort not to change too many things aside from removing the stones it really wouldn't have mattered if they did cause nothing done in that universe will affect their timeline. Think about it like the way time travel works in DBZ when trunks went back to the past it's the exact same thing but instead of multiverse theory, I guess it'd be called multi-timeline theory.

And the reason the stones had to be returned was not to preserve the original timeline but to persevere the newly created ones.

The only thing that doesn' make sense about this way of time travel is that returning to the same newly created timeline should be impossible cause returning to the past again would again create another splitting timeline. So yeah it's pretty much exactly the way time travel works in DBZ. How trunks was about to continuously return to the same timeline/universe.

June 7, 2019

I still don't understand how changing the past via time travel creates another timeline separate from the main one. Wouldn't the changes just overwrite the main timeline? Because you're traveling from point A to point B in your main timeline. How does changing something in the past created an entirely new reality with an entirely new timeline and timespace? It would make more sense for time travel to work like it does in X-men days of future past. The movie, not the comic.

June 9, 2019

Stoping a war before it starts just gets people kill. Thats Caps line on age of ultron.

June 9, 2019

People always die. You never lost a soldier?

June 15, 2019

But Cap could have gone Nomand and save people outside of America

June 21, 2019

I see the issue but what if he is using his own morals to counter his morals. Maybe Steve knows that if he intervened he could screw something up make things worse. It’s kind of like what thanos said “ I used the stones to destroy the stones”. Well Steve used his morals to stop his morals from taking over.

June 23, 2019

If steve changed anything from the past it wouldnt affect the future so if he stopped hydra it would do nothing

June 27, 2019

Cap said "Everytime someone tries to end a war before it starts innocent people die, everytime."

June 28, 2019

My question is what was the whole point of steve rogers and his team breaking the law and fighting iron man and his team for his best friend buckys freedom just to end up going back in time to be with peggy?

June 28, 2019

It's all FAKE!! what's the point of having the TIME STONE IF YOU CAN JUST BUILD A TIME MACHINE. Thanks is behind the scenes toying with reality (gem)

July 6, 2019

Fuk the captain America problem more like the thanos problem 2014 thanos didn’t have no reason to travel to 2023 because how time travel works in the movie since 2023 would be consider another timeline an wont affect his own . He could stayed in his timeline an just learn from his other timeline self

July 9, 2019

Thank you for this video. I don’t understand why Cap couldn’t have just retired and married in the future (if he had to be married). He created new timelines (probably?) and went back to a woman he kissed once, knowing that he also kissed and hit on her niece? Ugh Steve, pick a Carter. Or better yet, marry Maria Hill.

July 17, 2019

Steve Rogers went to the past to be with Peggy Carter knowing that Captain America was frozen solid in the Atlantic ocean. Cap will eventually be discovered by SHIELD 70 years later. Cap will follow the same exact events previously to Rogers. Rogers at this time will be a very old man hiding his identity. In Endgame Rogers knows exactly what time, date and location to hand the mantle to Falcon living the rest of his life as a veteran. Cap will go to the past to be with Peggy following a circular loop.

July 18, 2019

Him being there made a new timeline and he used quantum tech to travel back once he was old

August 3, 2019

No its another timeline. The directors even said it.

August 4, 2019

I wanna know what time timeline was Thors goatee braided

August 8, 2019

Yea it had to happen

August 22, 2019

Ur over thinkin this dude. He watched everythin happen because it already happened. He knew it would all work out. He finally lived his life which he unlike the rest of the Avengers…never got to do.

August 27, 2019

Cap should change the timeline

August 27, 2019

I'm SO glad I'm not the only one who found huge problems with the ending of Endgame. You're right, it was an awesome movie, and I loved it. That is, up until what they did to Steve. I… honestly would have rathered he die than what they did. And he's my favorite Marvel character. The insane stupidy of what they did with the timelines aside, they also made Steve into an ooc, selfish asshole. He's leader of the Avengers, and they expect us to believe he has no problem abandoning them at their lowest when they've just lost two key members to go back in time and fuck around with Peggy (who he moved on from. he went to the funeral, he grieved, he made out with another girl, it was over. it's been years, it's done) and leave them to pick up the pieces of their lives by themselves? Plus they somehow made it seem as if he was grieving Peggy throughout Endgame, rather than his two best friends, Bucky and Sam, whom he'd lost much more recently??? As you said, Steve promised Bucky he would be with him to the end of the line. No way would the Steve we've been presented with and come to know throughout the MCU, leave Bucky alone in the present, to go back in time and live out his life without him. Even Peggy would be appalled if she knew that's what Steve had done.

I've basically elected to treat everything after the funeral like it doesn't exist. Endgame ended with Tony and Nat's sendoff. Period. I will not acknowledge the horrible ooc mess they made of my favorite character. They cared more about wrapping things up in a pretty little bow that decimated Steve's character and the entire timeline, rather than giving us an ending that made sense and honored him. I'm still pretty furious tbh. 😅 Anyway, Marvel lost a huge fan with this. I won't be supporting any more Marvel movies from here on out.

August 29, 2019

yeah, he wouldn't ignore all the bad stuff going on… but he could assume a different alias (nomad?)… but hey, if I learned anything from crisis on two Earths (I know, DC thing for a Marvel theory): NOTHIN' MATTERS WHEN YOU HAVE A MULTIVERSE (why the Owlman wanted to blow it all up, because you could be a paragon of goodness and stuff… but with infinite possibilities, there's a version of you out there who's an incredible asshole)

September 3, 2019

once these half assed Hollywood writers start doing time travel,it means they just ran out of ideas and just said "we'll fix it with time travel".

Leave a comment
Stay up to date
Register now to get updates on promotions and coupons.

Shopping cart