There Was Always Two Captain America In The MCU (Avengers Endgame Theory)


The Tale of Two Captain Americas In The Marvel Cinematic Universe, As Seen During Avengers Endgame

SUBSCRIBE NOW to CBR! Click here:

Related CBR article:

Time travel can be a complicated thing. There’ve been many stories about people going into the past to affect the future and there’ve been just as many different sets of rules for how that time travel is supposed to work. Comic book stories aren’t above taking a trip through time and their cinematic counterparts have followed suit.

In the epic conclusion to the Marvel Cinematic Universe’s Infinity Saga, Avengers: Endgame, time travel played a key role in undoing Thanos’ deadly snap. This meant that not only did the Avengers visit their past adventures, but thanks to a mix up involving the Hulk and Loki, they also managed create some alternate timelines, as explained by the Ancient One. One of the big shocks in Endgame was when Steve Rogers took a detour at the end of his quest to return the stones to their original places in time. That last trip was to fulfil a promise he made all the way back in 1945 to Peggy Carter to return and have that dance that he missed out on when he saved the world from Hydra the first time. But did he create another reality where he was able to marry Peggy Carter or were there in fact two Captain Americas existing simultaneously in the MCU the entire time? Let’s look at how Captain America managed to co-exist next to a retired Steve Rogers in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.


Our Social Media:

Our Website

Find with tag :
Marvel Cinematic Universe,MCU Films,Steve Rogers,Captain America,Peggy Carter,Loki God Of Mischief,The Incredible Hulk,Avengers Endgame,Infinity Saga,time travel,Mad Titan Thanos,The Falcon,Sam Wilson,Red Skull,Hydra,SHIELD,MCU multiverse,CBR


Comments (22)
June 14, 2019

Peggy married veteran Captain America.

June 15, 2019

4:59 makes no sense. She was in love with him. He very much existed in her past. Besides if what you said was true, she would still query this "stranger" in her office. Oddly Peggy never saw him, that is the only thing that happened.

June 15, 2019

perhaps the one that comes out of the ice is the one that becomes captain hydra

June 17, 2019

Does anyone else wonder what happened to Daniel Sousa and the who Agent Carter timeline? I'm sure Cap wouldn't be too happy about her flirting and snogging someone else! It has to be a different timeline or it makes no sense!

June 18, 2019

There WERE* Always Two CAPTAIN Americas In The MCU

June 19, 2019

Dear YouTube. Fuck you and your ads

June 24, 2019

Many superheroes took retirement after the endgame movie

June 27, 2019

Cbr or screen rants theories about all this endgame stuff makes zero sense

July 25, 2019

If cap put all the stones back wouldn’t that mean all the branch timelines be fixed except for the one where Loki escaped with the tesseract so it’s technically only 2 timelines now and the main timeline cap went back to live with Peggy but he didn’t take any stones so it’s still part of the main timeline which means there is only one cap in the main timeline instead of 2. I mean I’m not sure if this works but it’s just a theory.

July 31, 2019

Yeah 2 caps the whole time!

August 4, 2019

i never heard anybody talk about this. but my questions is what did sharon carter peggy carter's niece. the sharon that was placed in an apartment next to capt by orders of nick fury, the same sharon that help steve, sam and bucky escape and also kissed steve, the next time we she sharon is at peggy's funeral. so if sharon and her aunt peggy was so close, wouldn't sharon who her uncle was peggy's husband. if sharon over to aunt peggy house she never saw a photo of her aunt and uncle, or seen aunt peggy wedding album. so they need to explain what sharon carter knew or did not know.

August 4, 2019

Doesn't make sense. So are they saying that, as
cap was talking to Peggy in Winter Soldier she
already knew the whole story which is in turn trying
to insinuate that she was pretending to have loss
of memory of a sort in that scene. This is messed
up. I don't think they should be switching between
writers like that, it creates a controversy and
inconsistency in the storyline
It's also contracts this scene , where Peggy says Cap saved the man that became her husband

August 4, 2019

so mcu time traveling is same as harry potter's time turner it is a loop

August 4, 2019

OMG! This theory opens a huge universe! There kids! Ofcourse!

August 6, 2019

It's just Mystique guys, don't argue… Grrrrrr hahhahahaha

August 8, 2019

This makes no sense. If he goes back in time, it's into an alternate reality. He can't go into his own past because his past is already past. That was explained in the movie several times

August 8, 2019

Bruce Banner: I don’t know why everyone believes that, but that isn’t true. Think about it, if you travel to the past, that past becomes your future. And your former present becomes the past. Which can’t now be changed by your new future.

August 12, 2019

I dont even get it

August 19, 2019

That means they can take Capt America, off ice in another battle

August 25, 2019

Imagine If Clint Eastwood played Old Captain America

September 16, 2019

Yes there was, the older one was waiting for the right time to give the shield to Sam. He is 310 years old.

October 19, 2019

Honestly I could figure out a way to make it work but in the end it doesn't matter, I am just happy Cap got to live his life with someone he loved. Call me crazy but he still seemed pretty spry I would like to think he restarted his work with the Avengers, not as Captain America of course but as a consultant or as what Ned calls the guy in the chair, using computers giving out info to the team maybe creating gadgets to use in the field, who knows what he learned in all that time, he could be a master engineer or computer specialist.

Leave a comment
Stay up to date
Register now to get updates on promotions and coupons.

Shopping cart